Toggle navigation
Set Up HRA
Set Up a QSEHRA
Set Up an ICHRA
Evaluating ICHRA vs. Group Health

Evaluating ICHRA vs. group health insurance?

How ICHRA (now called CHOICE Arrangement) compares with traditional group coverage

When it comes to benefits funding options, more and more employers are comparing Individual coverage HRAs to group health plans. Choosing the best option depends on your business. Get the facts so you can make an informed decision.

Talk with a pro
Mask Group - Stock - 12

Understanding ICHRA vs. group plan models

Employer options for funding health benefits

Traditional group health insurance is a defined benefits model, and ICHRA is defined contribution model. The main structural differences are who chooses the plan, how payments are made, and the pricing structure.

 

Traditional Group Health Insurance

ICHRA (now called CHOICE Arrangement)

Model

Defined benefits

Defined contributions

Plan selection

The employer chooses the healthcare plan for the company

Employees choose their own plan from healthcare.gov or a state marketplace

Payments

The employer pays a percentage of the premium

The employer allocates a monthly allowance for employees

Pricing

Variable: Determined by carrier, claims history, and risk pool

Fixed: Determined by employer

 

The main difference between ICHRA and a group plan

Group health insurance: The employer selects a plan and pays a share of the employee premium.

ICHRA: The employer sets a fixed monthly allowance for employees to buy their own plan.

Comparing employer health insurance options

When you’re considering an individual coverage HRA vs. a group health plan, there is a lot at stake. Neither is inherently better, it’s what works best for your business.

Decision factor

Traditional Group Health Insurance

ICHRA (now called CHOICE Arrangement)

Provider networks

Employer picks one health plan for the company, so everyone has access to the same list of doctors and hospitals.

Employees pick their own plan, so access to doctors and hospitals depends on the plan and region.

Geographic adaptability

Simple for employees in one region, more difficult for multi-state teams.

Location agnostic; uses the framework chosen by the employer.

Compliance mandates

ACA compliance mandates are built into the plan options.

Safe-harbor calculations are used to ensure compliance.

Plan portability

Tied to employment: Coverage ends when the employee leaves the company. They can elect temporary COBRA coverage at their own expense.

Owned by the employee: The health policy belongs to the individual. If they leave the company, they can keep the plan at their own expense.

Administrative workload

Front-loaded during plan renewal: handling carrier negotiations, plan design, and open enrollment.

Ongoing: reimbursing employee claims, confirming employees still have coverage, and reporting for taxes and payroll.

Employee experience

Familiar: Employees understand how group plans work. Copays, deductibles, and enrollment follow predictable norms.

Requires education: Employees learn how to select plans and use allowance, employer learns administrative requirements.

Risk pool

High employer vulnerability: Risk is shared among the employees on the company’s group plan (e.g. 50 or 100 people).

Low employer vulnerability: Risk is shared among the number of state participants (e.g. 501,000 people in Pennsylvania or 5.3 million in Florida).

 

ICHRA for Brokers

Employer contribution strategy

Group health insurance could be a good fit if:

  • Employees are concentrated in one area: Your workforce resides primarily in one region with good group rates and high-quality network access.

  • Individual markets are lacking: Your business operates in a (rural) area where the individual market offers a limited choice of healthcare providers.

  • Change management would be burdensome: You don’t have the bandwidth or desire to take on a new benefits model and prefer to stay with what you know.

ICHRA could be a good fit if:

  • Employees live in different states: You don’t want to buy multiple, state-specific group plans or pay extra for out-of-state networks.

  • A single plan would be limiting: You want your staff (from young singles to older employees with families) to have a health plan that meets their specific needs.

  • Fixed pricing would help you budget and/or reduce costs: You want to set a monthly health insurance allowance that doesn’t change unless you want it to.

Employer contribution strategy checklist

Start your evaluation by compiling:

Workforce data

Employee ZIP codes, ages, and individual or family coverage needs

Individual market premiums

Plan costs where employees live

Group plan history

Premiums and renewal increases from the past three to five years

Employer budget

Current benefits spending and target contribution budget

Why trust Take Command to help you evaluate

Weighing ICHRA against a group plan takes work. It requires running the numbers, understanding compliance, and knowing what actually works for your business.

Take Command is uniquely positioned to support employers. We offer deep health insurance experience and precise data modeling so you can confidently evaluate your benefits options.

And what’s just as important? If ICHRA isn’t a good fit for your business, we’ll tell you. Our goal is to provide information that helps you make a strategic decision.

Deep health insurance expertise

Customer-centric mission

Precise data modeling

Request a cost comparison

Request an evaluation of group vs. ICHRA

Talk to a Take Command about ICHRA vs group health insurance. We’ll use real-time market rates to model what you’re paying for group insurance versus what you’d spend with an ICHRA.

Resources for comparing ICHRA to group health insurance