Toggle navigation
group health insurance premiums going up

Group health insurance premiums keep going up? Here's what to do.

If you're an employer or HR professional, you've probably noticed that your health insurance costs go up each year. Are renewals a necessary evil of group health insurance? Maybe. But good news for you: There are options to consider that might help you get out from between a rock and a hard place. This article shares how to navigate best the potential rise in your group health insurance rate upon renewal and still offer great employee benefits.

Navigating Rising Health Insurance Costs: A Strategic Guide for Employers

In the ever-evolving landscape of business operations, one constant remains: the increasing cost of health insurance. Year after year, employers and HR professionals brace for the impact of rising health insurance premiums. This trend significantly affects both businesses' financial health and employees' well-being. The stark reality is that these costs have surged at a rate that far outpaces inflation, presenting a daunting challenge for companies striving to provide valuable employee benefits.

The Escalating Challenge of Health Insurance

Recent data from the Kaiser Family Foundation underscores this issue, revealing a 20% increase in employer-sponsored family coverage premiums over the last five years, with an even more staggering 43% rise over the past decade. Such figures are not just statistics; they represent a major hurdle for businesses, especially small and medium-sized enterprises, which must balance the desire to offer competitive employee benefits with the imperative of maintaining fiscal responsibility.

Escalating health insurance costs extend beyond the balance sheet, affecting employee satisfaction, retention, and morale. As premiums climb, the pressure to either reduce benefits or shift a greater share of costs to employees grows, potentially undermining the very objectives of offering health insurance: to attract, retain, and care for a productive and happy workforce.

Given these challenges, the need for strategic solutions has never been more acute. This blog is dedicated to exploring practical and innovative strategies to manage and potentially mitigate the rising costs of health insurance. From dissecting the drivers behind premium increases to examining alternatives like Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs), negotiating better rates, and implementing wellness programs, we aim to arm employers with the knowledge and tools they need to navigate this complex issue.

By examining a range of options, businesses can find tailored solutions that align with their unique needs and values, ensuring that they can continue to offer valuable employee benefits in a financially sustainable way. Join us as we delve into the intricacies of managing health insurance costs, seeking pathways supporting business health and employee well-being.

Understanding the Surge in Premiums

Why do health insurance premiums prices increase each year? Let’s find out.

Factors Driving Costs

The escalating premiums of health insurance are influenced by a confluence of factors, making it a multifaceted issue for businesses across the board. Market conditions play a significant role, with the health insurance industry subjecting the same economic pressures and competitive dynamics as any other market. Changes in healthcare demand, the entry of new providers, and shifts in regulatory policies can all impact premium costs.

Employee demographics are another critical driver. As the workforce ages or if employees live in areas with high healthcare costs or limited medical resources, insurance providers adjust premiums to account for these increased risks. Furthermore, the rising cost of medical services and prescription drugs significantly contributes to premium hikes. While often beneficial, medical technology and treatment innovations come with higher price tags, subsequently driving up insurance costs.

The Impact on Businesses

Businesses are deeply affected by the ripple effects of rising health insurance costs. Financially, higher premiums strain budgets, forcing companies to reassess their spending across all areas of operation. This financial pressure may lead to difficult decisions, such as reducing the scope of benefits offered or increasing the share of costs passed on to employees, affecting employee satisfaction and retention. Employees who suddenly find their health benefits diminished or their contributions increased may feel undervalued, leading to decreased morale and loyalty.

From a strategic standpoint, companies facing these pressures may find it challenging to compete for top talent. In industries where high-quality benefits packages are a key differentiator, escalating costs can erode a firm's competitive edge, making it harder to attract and retain the skilled individuals who drive business success.

Strategic Options for Employers

Faced with the challenge of rising health insurance premiums, employers have at their disposal a variety of strategies to mitigate impact and maintain robust benefits offerings. The goal is not merely to cut costs but to do so in a way that preserves, or even enhances, the value of the health benefits package for employees. By exploring innovative solutions and making informed, strategic decisions, businesses can navigate the complexities of health insurance in a way that supports both their financial health and their employees' well-being.

In the following sections, we will explore several strategic options for employers. There are numerous avenues to explore, from transitioning to alternative models like Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs), negotiating more favorable terms with insurance providers, adopting high-deductible health plans supplemented by Health Savings Accounts (HSAs), and implementing wellness programs. Each option comes with its own set of considerations, benefits, and challenges, offering different ways for businesses to address the issue of rising costs while continuing to support their workforce effectively.

Understanding the factors driving health insurance premiums and their impact on businesses and employees alike can help employers better navigate their options. The strategic approaches outlined offer a starting point for businesses looking to tackle this complex issue, ensuring they can continue to offer valuable benefits sustainably.

Option 1: Transition to Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs)

Explaining HRAs

Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs) represent a flexible and cost-effective alternative to traditional group health insurance plans. An HRA is an employer-funded plan reimburses employees for qualified medical expenses, including premiums for individual health insurance policies, up to a set limit. This arrangement allows employers to contribute towards their employees' health care costs without needing a traditional group health insurance plan. One of the key features of HRAs is their tax efficiency: reimbursements made through an HRA are tax-free for employees, provided they are used for qualified expenses and tax-deductible for employers.

Types of HRAs

There are two main types of HRAs designed to suit businesses of different sizes and needs:

Qualified Small Employer HRA (QSEHRA): Specifically tailored for small businesses with fewer than 50 full-time equivalent employees, QSEHRAs allow employers to set aside a fixed amount of money each month that employees can use to pay for individual health insurance premiums and other qualified medical expenses. QSEHRAs offer a simple way for small businesses to provide health benefits without the complexity or cost of managing a traditional group plan.

Individual Coverage HRA (ICHRA): ICHRAs are available to organizations of any size and offer greater flexibility than QSEHRAs. Employers can customize their contributions based on different classes of employees, such as full-time, part-time, or seasonal workers, and even vary benefits based on geographic locations. This customization makes ICHRAs particularly appealing to larger businesses or those with diverse workforces.

Benefits of HRAs

Flexibility: HRAs provide significant flexibility regarding employer contributions and how employees can use their benefits. Employers can adjust their funding levels yearly, while employees can choose the individual insurance plans that best meet their needs and preferences.

Cost Control: Businesses have complete control over their health benefits budget by defining the amount allocated to each employee. This predictability starkly contrasts traditional health insurance premiums, which can fluctuate significantly.

Predictability: With HRAs, any unused funds remain with the employer at the end of the year, unlike traditional insurance premiums, which are a sunk cost. This feature gives employers a more predictable and often more cost-effective way of offering health benefits.

Personalization: HRAs empower employees to make their own decisions regarding health insurance. Instead of being confined to the options selected by their employer, employees can use their HRA funds to purchase the insurance that best fits their circumstances, including the doctors they prefer and the coverage levels they need.

Transitioning to an HRA can be a strategic move for businesses looking to manage rising health insurance costs while continuing to support their employees’ health care needs. By offering a blend of flexibility, cost control, predictability, and personalization, HRAs present a viable and attractive alternative to traditional group health insurance plans.

Option 2: Negotiate for Better Rates

The Power of Negotiation

In the face of rising health insurance premiums, the art of negotiation emerges as a potent tool for employers. Engaging in open, transparent discussions with your insurance brokers or providers can pave the way to uncovering more affordable rates for your group health insurance plan. This proactive approach requires a readiness to effectively communicate your company's financial constraints and healthcare needs, ensuring your broker or provider fully understands the impact of premium increases on your business.

Negotiation isn't just about seeking a reduction in costs; it's about fostering a partnership where both parties find value. Prepare for these discussions by gathering comprehensive data on your employees' healthcare usage, claims history, and any specific needs that could influence your insurance plan. With this information, you can advocate for rates that reflect your actual usage and needs rather than a one-size-fits-all premium increase.

Exploring Plan Options

Diversifying your search to include different types of group plans can also lead to significant savings. Insurance providers offer a range of plans, from traditional fully-funded options to level-funded and self-funded plans, each with its own set of benefits and considerations. For example, level-funded plans can offer the predictability of fixed monthly payments with the potential for refunds on unused claims funds, appealing to businesses looking for cost control with some degree of risk-sharing.

Similarly, transitioning to a high-deductible health plan (HDHP) could yield lower monthly premiums. While HDHPs come with higher out-of-pocket costs before insurance kicks in, pairing them with Health Savings Accounts (HSAs) can offer employees a tax-advantaged way to cover these expenses. This shift not only has the potential to reduce the company's premium costs but also engages employees in more actively managing their healthcare spending.

When exploring these options, consider the makeup of your workforce and their specific healthcare needs. Younger, healthier employee groups might benefit more from an HDHP due to lower utilization rates. At the same time, a workforce with diverse medical needs might find more value in a traditional PPO plan despite its higher premium costs. Each type of plan carries its own risk and reward balance, so it is crucial to assess what aligns best with your company's financial health and employee well-being.

In conclusion, negotiating for better rates and exploring diverse plan options can significantly mitigate the financial burden of rising health insurance premiums. By taking a strategic approach to these discussions and being open to exploring various plan structures, employers can find sustainable paths to offering valuable health benefits. Engaging with knowledgeable brokers and conducting thorough research are key steps in navigating this complex landscape effectively.

Option 3: Implementing Wellness Programs

Benefits Beyond Insurance

Wellness programs offer more than just insurance coverage; they play a pivotal role in enhancing employee health and potentially reducing healthcare expenses in the long run. By focusing on preventive measures rather than reactive treatments, these programs contribute to overall well-being, leading to decreased reliance on medical interventions and, consequently, lower insurance claims and premiums. Moreover, investing in employee wellness demonstrates a commitment to their welfare, fostering job satisfaction and improving retention rates. Additionally, healthier lifestyle choices promoted through wellness initiatives can result in a more energized, focused, and productive workforce.

Examples of Effective Programs

  • Fitness Challenges and Gym Memberships: Initiating company-wide fitness challenges or subsidizing gym memberships encourages employee physical activity, improving health and vitality. Whether organizing step count competitions or facilitating team sports activities, such initiatives promote physical well-being and foster a sense of camaraderie and teamwork within the organization.
  • Mental Health Support: Offering access to mental health resources, such as counseling services or stress management workshops, addresses the crucial aspect of emotional well-being. Supporting mental health issues helps employees cope with stress, anxiety, and other challenges, contributing to a more balanced and resilient workforce.

Option 4: Adjusting Employee Contributions

A Common but Unpopular Solution

With rising health insurance premiums, some businesses increase employee contributions to contain costs. While this approach may offer short-term relief for employers grappling with escalating healthcare expenses, it has potential downsides. Heightened employee contributions can strain workers' finances, leading to dissatisfaction and reduced morale. Moreover, imposing greater financial burdens on employees may adversely impact retention rates and hinder recruitment efforts, particularly in competitive job markets where attractive benefits packages are paramount.

Making the Transition: Practical Steps and Support

Despite the challenges associated with adjusting employee contributions, some businesses may find it necessary to explore this option. If your organization is considering a shift to alternative cost-saving measures, such as transitioning to Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs), it's essential to approach the process strategically and with the right support.

Action Plan

  • Evaluate Current Benefits Structure: Conduct a comprehensive review of your organization's current benefits structure, including health insurance offerings and employee contribution rates. Identify areas of potential cost savings and assess the feasibility of implementing alternative benefit strategies.
  • Educate Employees: Transparent communication is key when making changes to employee benefits. Educate your workforce about the reasons behind the proposed adjustments and the potential impact on their contributions and coverage. Address any concerns or questions they may have and emphasize your commitment to maintaining valuable benefits for employees.
  • Explore Alternative Benefit Options: Research alternative benefit options, such as HRAs, that offer cost-effective solutions while providing valuable employee coverage. Consider flexibility, cost control, and employee satisfaction when evaluating different benefit strategies.
  • Implement Changes Gradually: If transitioning to a new benefits structure, such as implementing HRAs, introduce changes gradually to minimize disruption and allow employees time to adjust. Provide ample support and resources to assist employees throughout the transition process.

Partnering with Experts

Navigating the complexities of transitioning employee benefits requires expertise and guidance. Partnering with HR administration software providers, like Take Command, and consulting services can streamline the process and ensure compliance with regulatory requirements. These experts offer invaluable support in implementing cost-saving measures effectively while prioritizing the well-being of your workforce. From assisting with plan design and enrollment to providing ongoing support and training, partnering with experts can help ease the transition and set your organization up for success in managing rising healthcare costs.

Navigating Rising Healthcare Costs

In conclusion, managing the escalating costs of health insurance presents a significant challenge for employers. It requires strategic planning and proactive measures to ensure the organization's financial health while maintaining valuable benefits for employees. Businesses can navigate this complex landscape and mitigate the impact of rising healthcare expenses by understanding the factors driving premium increases and exploring alternative options such as Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs).

Employers must consider the broader implications of healthcare costs on company finances and employee satisfaction, recognizing the importance of prioritizing the well-being of their workforce. Implementing wellness programs, negotiating for better rates, and adjusting employee contributions are additional strategies businesses can explore to manage rising premiums effectively.

Ultimately, partnering with experts in HR administration software and consulting services can provide valuable support in implementing cost-saving measures and ensuring compliance with regulatory requirements. By taking a proactive and strategic approach to managing healthcare costs, employers can protect their organizations' financial stability while continuing to provide valuable benefits that attract and retain top talent.



Let's talk through your HRA questions

Fill out the form below to connect with our team and see if an HRA is a good fit.