Toggle navigation
Can an employer contribute different amounts to different employees

Can employers contribute different amounts to different employees?

Can employers contribute different amounts to different employees? The short answer is yes! Employers can contribute different amounts toward different employees' healthcare costs. With health reimbursement arrangements like ICHRA (Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement), employers can customize a plan tailored to their organization. 

 

Can An Employer Contribute Different Amounts to different employees? 

As we mentioned the answer is yes! The federal government doesn't require the same health care coverage for all employees. The Affordable Care Act only requires employers who employ 50 or more full-time employees to offer health care coverage or pay a fine. However, that rule doesn't extend to part-time employees. 

Why, you ask?

It's thanks to classes. An employer is allowed to set up different classes of employees within their organization and offer them different benefits.

This strategy is often used to save on healthcare costs or offer more competitive benefits to certain roles.

Ask our experts which option is best for your business

What’s the catch? 

There isn't a catch, but employers do need to follow the rules laid out by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission Compliance Manual of Employee Benefits, Section 3, to prevent discrimination.

An employer, for example, cannot divide employees by things like gender or disabilities. Classes need to be structured by job-based criteria like hours worked or geographic locations. 

Can I create my own employee classes? 

No, you can’t create your own classes.

The IRS laid out the following classes for the ICHRA (Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement).

  • Full-time employees
  • Part-time employees
  • Employees working in the same geographic location (due to same insurance markets)
  • Seasonal employees
  • Employees in a unit of employees covered by a particular collective bargaining agreement
  • Employees who have not completed a waiting period
  • Non-residents with no U.S. -based income
  • Non-salaried workers
  • Temporary employees of staffing firms
  • Any group of employees formed by combining two or more of these classes

    → Learn about ICHRA Classes

The IRS also says when offering an ICHRA, the employer must offer the same terms to all employees within a class. 

But they offer an exception.

An employer may offer increased contributions for older employees and employees with more dependents. 

Wait! Isn’t that discrimination?

Discrimination and Employee Classes 

The IRS allows for higher contribution amounts based on age or dependents to ensure the ICHRA reimbursement amounts cover the premium of the insurance costs. If an employer offers a higher contribution amount for older employees, they must not exceed a 3:1 ratio. 

→ Learn about ICHRA Rules

→ Learn about ICHRA Requirements 

QSEHRA and Employee Classes 

I have a QSEHRA. Can I use classes? 

A QSEHRA (Qualified Small Employer Health Reimbursement Arrangement) is often used for small employers who don’t fall under the ACA employer mandate. You can’t create classes like outlined by the IRS for ICHRA. However, you can offer different contribution amounts to full-time vs. part-time employees and employees with dependents. 

Traditional Group Plans and Employee Classes 

What about traditional group plans?

Traditional group health insurance is complex and works fundamentally differently than HRAs. An employer may offer a plan or a selection of plans for the employee to choose from. The employer can also determine their own classes as long as they adhere to the ACA full-time employee mandate and do not base classes on a discriminatory basis laid out by the EEOC. 

Can I offer a group health insurance plan to some employees and an ICHRA to others? 

Yes! An employer can offer a group health insurance plan to some employees and an ICHRA to others based on classes such as; full-time vs. part-time, salary vs. non-salary, or geographic location. However, a minimum class rule applies to prevent adverse selection in the individual market. 

What is a minimum class size? 

The minimum class size for ICHRA is: 

  • Ten employees for an employer will fewer than 100 employees
  • Ten percent of the total number of employees for an employer with 100 to 200 employees
  • Twenty employees for an employer with more than 200 employees

The IRS also allows for new hires to be onboarded into an ICHRA while existing employers are grandfathered into their current healthcare plan regardless of class. 

→ Read up on ICHRA and the New Hire Provision 

Summary

While it’s possible for an employer to contribute different amounts to different employees or offer them completely different health care plans, it’s important to follow the rules to prevent discrimination or adverse selection of the insurance markets. To ensure rules and requirements don’t go overlooked it’s wise to hire a plan administrator (like us!).

Take Command has helped thousands of clients setup and administer their own reimbursement programs. Part of our process is to establish legal plan documents for the IRS and Department of labor to keep your organization in compliance with these types of rules and regulations.

→ To learn more about our process, visit our ICHRA Guide

→ You can also check out our HRA platform demo

→ Or read up on our ICHRA administration offerings 

 

Ask our experts how to get started today (it's easy!)

 

Up Next